Trade on minutes!

Всех приветствую! Я хочу поделиться с вами некоторыми соображениями по поводу торговли на минутных графиках. Я не буду говорить, что это уже полноценная торговая стратегия со всеми необходимыми неизвестными, но данный метод лично мне нравится. Я хотел бы получить побольше обоснованной критики, и возможно тогда я и пойму, чего именно здесь мне и не хватает.

Сегодня не самое лучшее время для торговли, но тем не менее я решил не откладывать анализ еще на 2-3 недели. Вот сегодняшние 2 сделки. https://forexdengi.com/attachment.php?s=c24d022c311f5518f8cbd0a98ea14020&attachmentid=1736418&d=1514300112&thumb=1" border="0" alt="Нажмите на изображение для увеличения
Название: 2017-12-26_17-42-40.png
Просмотров: 4718
Размер: 46.2 КБ
ID: 1736418" class="thumbnail" style='margin-top: 10px'>[/url][url=https://forexdengi.com/attachment.php?s=c24d022c311f5518f8cbd0a98ea14020&attachmentid=1736420&d=1514300164][img]https://forexdengi.com/attachment.php?s=c24d022c311f5518f8cbd0a98ea14020&attachmentid=1736420&d=1514300164&thumb=1" border="0" alt="Нажмите на изображение для увеличения
Название: 2017-12-26_17-44-29.png
Просмотров: 3181
Размер: 42.5 КБ
ID: 1736420" class="thumbnail" style='margin-top: 10px'>[/url]

Я попробую объяснить идею. Я смотрю по индикатору силы валют расстановку сил на 10-11 утра, и беру в работу крайние валюты, самые сильные и самые слабые. Открываю 2-3 валютных пары, которые образуют эти валюты. Дальше я вхожу в рынок при откате в сторону более сильной валюты. Стоп я ставлю в районе 20-30п. по основным валютным парам и до 50п. по EURAUD и GBPCAD к примеру. Уровень ТР я не ставлю, ну или где-то из расчета среднедневной волатильности. При прохождении ценой расстояния равного стопу я переношу стоп в б.у.

В итоге что я получаю, я иду в сторону более сильной валюты на текущий момент, при этом продаю наиболее слабую на текущий момент. То есть есть потенциальное движение, на которое я рассчитываю. Да, все может измениться, поэтому есть стоп. Почему стоп большой, т.к. иногда цена показала хороший импульс, и может быть некий откат, хотя здесь так же есть свои моменты. По основным валютным парам совсем другая торговля, нежели по мажорам.

Пока писал, закрыл ТР.[url=https://forexdengi.com/attachment.php?s=c24d022c311f5518f8cbd0a98ea14020&attachmentid=1736424&d=1514300686][img]https://forexdengi.com/attachment.php?s=c24d022c311f5518f8cbd0a98ea14020&attachmentid=1736424&d=1514300686&thumb=1" border="0" alt="Нажмите на изображение для увеличения
Название: 2017-12-26_18-04-20.png
Просмотров: 3057
Размер: 42.0 КБ
ID: 1736424" class="thumbnail" style='margin-top: 10px'>[/url]
 
Now learn more about the rules and today's deals. The main trend for the Euro is up, I marked a potential pivot point and began to watch the strength indicator readings. The Euro did not fall below 20% in strength, and the dollar did not rise above 70%, which is some extreme values for me, and therefore I expected a resumption of movement along the main trend. I entered the market and made a profit.

I could have entered later, when changing the strength readings, and get a smaller profit when working solely on the imbalance of currency forces, but I entered here.

The same for EURJPY, upward movement, pullback and entry with the same readings. If the price goes down, but the currency forces do not go to extreme values, this means that the market is calmer, and it is unlikely to talk about a strong trend. So you can safely try to work in the direction of the main trend at the time of changing the strength indicator readings.

At the same time so you can work only on the major currency pairs, crosses and majors is better to take only market in the direction of the current trend, not subject to reversal. There were no such deals today, I think after the holidays.

I don't know if it was possible to explain at least in General terms, I think with examples it will be clearer.
 
Сегодня покажу по примерам, и попробую описать сам принцип, и сопутствующие проблемные моменты. Вот сегодняшние сделки.

<a class="mt5-inner-image]
[/url]
https://forexdengi.com/attachment.php?s=c24d022c311f5518f8cbd0a98ea14020&attachmentid=1737206&d=1514371509&thumb=1" border="0" alt="Нажмите на изображение для увеличения
Название: 2017-12-27_10-48-21.png
Просмотров: 3077
Размер: 29.6 КБ
ID: 1737206" class="thumbnail" style='margin-top: 10px'>[/url][url=https://forexdengi.com/attachment.php?s=c24d022c311f5518f8cbd0a98ea14020&attachmentid=1737207&d=1514371540][img]https://forexdengi.com/attachment.php?s=c24d022c311f5518f8cbd0a98ea14020&attachmentid=1737207&d=1514371540&thumb=1" border="0" alt="Нажмите на изображение для увеличения
Название: 2017-12-27_10-46-03.png
Просмотров: 3072
Размер: 30.0 КБ
ID: 1737207" class="thumbnail" style='margin-top: 10px'>[/url][url=https://forexdengi.com/attachment.php?s=c24d022c311f5518f8cbd0a98ea14020&attachmentid=1737208&d=1514371622][img]https://forexdengi.com/attachment.php?s=c24d022c311f5518f8cbd0a98ea14020&attachmentid=1737208&d=1514371622&thumb=1" border="0" alt="Нажмите на изображение для увеличения
Название: 2017-12-27_12-04-40.png
Просмотров: 2885
Размер: 31.9 КБ
ID: 1737208" class="thumbnail" style='margin-top: 10px'>[/url]

Итак, по расстановке сил была следующая ситуация, я открыл 3 сделки, учитывал направление основного тренда и покупал ауди по наиболее подходящим на мой взгляд парам. Как видите, я открывался с места, даже не стал ждать откат, просто работал по цене на текущий момент.

Чуть позже я взял еще NZDUSD и на определенный момент у меня была вот такая ситуация.

[url=https://forexdengi.com/attachment.php?s=c24d022c311f5518f8cbd0a98ea14020&attachmentid=1737213&d=1514371847][img]https://forexdengi.com/attachment.php?s=c24d022c311f5518f8cbd0a98ea14020&attachmentid=1737213&d=1514371847&thumb=1" border="0" alt="Нажмите на изображение для увеличения
Название: 2017-12-27_12-25-55.png
Просмотров: 3044
Размер: 57.8 КБ
ID: 1737213" class="thumbnail" style='margin-top: 10px'>[/url]

И как видите, по дальнейшей ситуации рынок особо то лучше войти и не давал. То есть на сейчас вход по цене был оправдан, кроме AUDCHF, здесь стоп до сих пор в убыточной зоне.
 
The main problem is that in most cases it is necessary to enter the market, because with such entries, the market rarely gives a better entry, which makes it necessary to use a large stop in case of a rollback. And pullbacks are also not so rare to talk about giving up such a stop.

Yes, you can take a smaller stop, and then re-enter the market at a better price, maybe this will still be an option. I want to upload screenshots here, and while I'm discussing, there will be some statistics on signal processing, you can edit the stop size, because this stop personally confuses me.

But the indicator readings a little later, I added another trade on NZDJPY, moved the stop on Audi / franc, raised the stop on Audi/yen higher, closed the new Zealander and opened a new order. The screenshot shows everything.

<a class="mt5-inner-image]
[/url]
https://forexdengi.com/attachment.php?s=c24d022c311f5518f8cbd0a98ea14020&attachmentid=1737227&d=1514372496&thumb=1 "border=" 0 "alt=" Click on the image to enlarge
Name: 2017-12-27_14-01-13. png
Views: 74
Size: 64.1 KB
ID: 1737227" class="thumbnail" style='margin-top: 10px'>[/url]

The yen was the weakest, the new Zealander was the strongest, and I entered the market again. But now it is already clear that there is a correction, whether it will be strong, it is not clear. This is a minus of such an entry, you enter the market with the direction already visible, and there is a risk of entering at the top. Yes, there is always a risk, and it is in every transaction, but I would like to understand that in this case it is the need for such an entry, or the validity.
 
Hello everyone, today the dollar is the weakest, with the indicator below 10 percent, opened 6 deals, sold the dollar everywhere on the market, let's see what the deals will show by lunch. By the way, NZDJPY rolled back to the point of yesterday's entry, it would be possible not to close, but to leave the deal in the market with the current stop, it would be possible to avoid a loss, which would give a better result for yesterday.
 
Good afternoon, OK. However, there are certain points, if the broker has abbreviations in the names of currency pairs, such as EURUSDm, Or something else, the indicator will not work. There is also no source code. In addition, if you switch the time period on the chart where the indicator is installed, it may get lost and not work. This does not always happen, or rather not at all brokers, but different traders wrote about all these moments at different times.

I have, for example, this indicator is on Roboforex, and I trade on another broker, I open it in the morning and look at the readings. Since the readings are too often not required to look, I look 1 time in a couple of hours. Of all the indicators of currency strength, I still like this one the most in my work, so I have to endure all the shortcomings and adapt to work with it.
 
Today, the dollar is also the weakest currency. The readings are not as low as yesterday, around 20%. I will take the same pairs as yesterday against the dollar, in the evening I will throw a screen of what happened. If the balance of power will change during the day, then unsubscribe on transactions and throw new ones.
 
Today is the same situation as the day before yesterday. All the signals that were taken around lunch brought a loss, but the morning deals brought a good plus. For GBPAUD, the profit took literally 5-10p. Now the price has gone a little higher, but not significantly. EURAUD received a stop on the 35P deal. AUDJPY received a stop 27P. But transactions against the dollar I closed somewhere 160p. profit. That is, today somewhere under 90-95P.in the black.

https://forexdengi.com/attachment.php?s=c24d022c311f5518f8cbd0a98ea14020&attachmentid=1739819&d=1514571351&thumb=1 "border=" 0 "alt=" Click on the image to enlarge
Name: 2017-12-29_21-11-36. png
Views: 77
Size: 74.1 KB
ID: 1739819" class="thumbnail" style='margin-top: 10px'>[/url]

Yes, and the new Zealander made it possible to move the stop to zero, but I did not move it in time, and closed the deal with a loss.

The third day is in the black, this is what confuses me, I have been watching the dynamics of signals for more than a month, and without any analysis, the result is better than I trade with my hands. We need to look into this carefully.
 

Andrewmaw

New member
Drain vehicle, definitely not for manual work. bounce levels are the levels of price accumulation so the price must return there at least 2 or even 3 times that there would be an entry.

The charts do not show where the stop level is, although it resembles the levels of technical analysis: head and shoulders. 2ное bottom/top.

Sobstvenno the author has nothing new to give not found.I used to play with such nonsense before, with a strong trend, its levels will break 3 times and with a reversal, this is a new point, a new level, there will be no signal



The only thing is that it works on the clock but there should be a stop of 20 points
 
You probably don't quite understand, there are no levels here. These are levels just from my work schedule in the first posts, there are no further levels. I enter on an imbalance of forces by 10 o'clock in the morning somewhere. I close in the evening, if there is no important news, if the day is calm. If news is expected, then I cut at the total profit, but if it is not, then already according to the situation. No levels, entry points for the market, at the current price with a significant imbalance of forces in currencies. These are all entry conditions, without levels.

And by the level of the stop, how can it not be seen? For all trades, the stop mark is visible. When entering the stop in the area of 30-50p. depending on the currency pair, I wrote about it.
 
<a class="mt5-inner-image]
[/url]
Good morning, for now the situation is as follows, the currency strength indicator readings differ from 25% to 60%. at the same time, there is also some fluctuation, this is understandable. The difference in the strength of currencies is only 2 times, this is too small a gap, with such a gap, you should not trade, because you should not talk about any imbalance of forces. Yes, the price for some pairs may be significantly changed during the day, but I do not understand yet what currency pairs this will happen, and whether it will be at all. So for now, I don't enter the market at current readings.
 
Top